Design of Drive System for
Head-On-Generation through Slip-Power Recovery in Passenger Electric
Locomotives
C. Nagamani*, R. Somanatham**
*Research
Scholar, University College of Engineering, Osmania
University, Hyderabad, India.
**HOD, Dept. Of Electrical & Electronics Engineering, Anurag College of Engineering, Hyderabad, India
*Corresponding Author Email: cnagamani2025@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Train Lighting and Air-Conditioning is an important
aspect of Passenger Coaches and for Trains like the Shatabdi/Rajdhani/Durunto/Double-Deckers/Garib-Rath which run on
the Indian Railways, the Power for the Lighting and Air-Conditioning Systems is
generated from the Diesel Generator Cars attached on either ends of the Train.
This is called End-On-Generation. The use of End-on-Generation which causes lot
of noise and air pollution can be eliminated if the Power supply is derived
from the Locomotive itself. The authors of this Research Paper intend to
propose a Drive System for Traction in which Squirrel Cage Induction Motors
will be replaced with Wound Rotor Induction Motor as Traction Motors with a low-Voltage
Slip-Power on the Rotor side to Drive the Lighting and Air-Conditioning Loads
of the Trailing Passenger Coaches which will be called Head-On-Generation.
KEYWORDS: Air-conditioning
System, Efficiency, Electric Traction, End-on-Generation, Head-on-Generation,
Slip Power Recovery, Squirrel Cage Induction Motor, Wound Rotor Induction
Motor.
1.
INTRODUCTION:
Rajdhani, Shatabdi, Durunto, Double-Deckers and Garib-Rath are the
premium fully Air-Conditioned semi-high Speed Passenger Trains on the network
of Indian Railways. These Trains are mostly hauled by High Horse-Power Electric
Locomotives of the range of 6000 HP on the electrified sections and
Diesel-Electric Locomotives on the non-electrified sections. The Power required
for the Lighting Equipment, Fans and the Air-Conditioning Units is supplied
from the Power Cars which house Diesel-Generator Sets. This method of supplying
Power to the Passenger Coaches is called End-On-Generation (EOG). The EOG Power
Cars cause a lot of noise and air pollution, are also energy inefficient and
cause lot of Vibrations [1].
They also
operate with poor power factor of about 0.4 to 0.6 lag requiring a good amount
of Reactive Power compensation. To eliminate the use of Power Generator Cars
for supplying Power to the Passenger Coaches, the Authors propose a Traction
Drives System with Wound Rotor Induction Motors(WRIM) as Traction Motors with a
low Voltage Slip-Power Recovery Scheme to deliver Power to the Passenger
Coaches.
2.
LITERATURE SURVEY:
The Literature
Survey undertaken for this Research Paper is described in the following three
sub-sections. The Authors made a detailed study of the existing EOG in Indian
Railways, the low Voltage Slip-Power Recovery Scheme in Stone Grinding Mills of
Australia and the Scope for conservation of Energy in the EOG in Indian
Railways to propose this Design of Drive System to generate Power from the
Traction Motors to deliver Power to the Passenger Coaches.
2.1
THE END-ON-GENERATION SYSTEM IN INDIAN RAILWAYS:
This scheme of
Generation of Power is used in Trains like Rajdhani
and Shatabdi. The EOG consists of a Diesel Generator
of rating of 500 kW [1], [2]. There are two such Power Cars in each of the Shatabdi/Rajdhani Expresses. The
DG sets generate 3-ph, 415 V, 50 Hz AC which is fed to the two roof mounted
Air-Conditioning Units in each Air-Conditioned Coach by means of feeders. For
Lighting and Fans in the Coaches, a Step-Down Transformer is used in the Power
Car itself which is rated at 2.5/5kVA. The Stepped down Voltage of 3-ph, 110 V,
50 Hz AC is directly fed to the Lights and Fans connected between each Phase
and Neutral (Balanced Loading). The 3-ph Evaporator Blower Motor is also
connected to this Circuit. The Schematic Diagram of EOG system is shown in
Fig.1.The Disadvantages of EOG are noise and air pollution, Vibrations, cost of
Fuel, Voltage Drop, reduction in Passenger capacity equivalent of two Coaches
and requirement of extra Staff for operation. The advantage is that this Power
Car can work irrespective of the type of Traction with 100 % reliability of
operation.
2.2
WOUND ROTOR INDUCTION MOTOR AND LOW VOLTAGE SLIP-POWER RECOVERY SCHEME:
Wound Rotor
Induction Motors are ideally suited for Applications which involve high Inertia
Loads, high Starting Torque with low Starting Current on a weak Power System
and better Speed Control [4]. The Study of one such Application in a Stone
Grinding Plant in Australia has proved that for a 5000 kW WRIM, the savings per
annum would be about $500000as the Slip-Power recovered by using low Voltage
Slip-Power Recovery Drive was 970 kW per Hour per WRIM. It has also been
mentioned that for Applications like Traction where Braking has to be robust
and at the same Time when Braking Torque has to be maximum, a WRIM is best
option as the introduction of External Resistances in the Rotor Circuit during
Braking results in high Slip resulting in high Braking Torque as the Torque
developed is proportional to Slip [3]. With modern manufacturing Technology it
is possible to manufacture WRIM with either Automatic Brush Lifting Gear such
that Slip-Rings are required only during Starting after which the Brushes are
lifted or with Permanent Slip-Rings Grooved eliminating the frequent
maintenance [5]. Also, the WRIMs are more efficient as compared to Squirrel
Cage Induction Motors, have higher Starting Torque with low Starting Current
and can be operated in a weak Power System without disturbing it. Hence, if a
WRIM is used for Traction, it can deliver the required constant Torque and also
help in supplying Power to the Trailing Passenger coaches through the low
Voltage Slip-Power Recovery System thus eliminating the use of EOG Power Cars
at least partially if not fully.
2.3
ENERGY REQUIREMENTS OF PASSENGER CARS:
The Passenger
Cars of the Shatabdi/Rajdhani
Express Trains are fully Air-Conditioned. The Coaches are constantly cooled by
roof mounted Air-Conditioning Units rated at 11.5 kW each. The Power Consumption
of the Coaches vary with their configuration. The Various Coach Configuration
that are used in the Shatabdi and Rajdhani
along with their Weights and the Power Consumed are listed in Table No.1 and 2
respectively. The Lights and Fans in the Coaches consume about 5 kW Power. The
average consumption of Energy by the Trains for Air-Conditioning and Lighting
is about 400 Units per Hour whereas the Locomotive itself requires only 1400
Units per Hour for Traction. The Energy requirements of the Coaches of the Shatabdi/Rajdhani Expresses are
entirely met by EOG.
2.4
ENERGY CONSERVATION:
There is lot of
scope of Energy Conservation in these types of Trains. The Diesel consumed by
the Power Cars for generating energy is 100 litres/Hour.
If part of the Air-Conditioning Load is taken over by the Locomotive, lot of
Fuel can be saved. Also if Sun-Films are used for the Windows of the Passenger
Coaches, the heat flow through the Windows will considerably reduce bringing
down the Load on Air-Conditioners. Also use of individual Cooling control in
Cubicles for each Passenger as it is in Aircrafts will also reduce Energy
Consumption. Lastly use of LEDs for lighting will considerably reduce the
Reactive Power Consumption as the Power Factor in the current Technology used
is very poor and is in the range of 0.4 lag to 0.6 lag [1]. By providing an
extra Auxiliary Winding in the Traction Transformer to aid the Power Supply
from the low Voltage Slip-Power Recovery (SPR) Scheme whenever the Locomotive
is Stationary or running at near rated Speed, lot of Costly Fossil Fuel can be
saved. Also, the levels of Pollution due to Diesel-Generator Sets can be
brought down thus saving the Environment.
3.
PROPOSED CIRCUIT, SIMULATIONS AND RESULTS:
The Drive System
for Electric Traction with WRIM as Traction Motors with a low Voltage
Slip-Power Recovery System to deliver Power to the Trailing Passenger Coaches
is proposed and the results of the Simulation Studies are discussed in this
Section. The Main Drive System consists of a 10 MVA Traction Transformer with
Primary Winding Voltage of 25 kV, 1-ph, 50 Hz, AC. On the Secondary side four
Tapings of each with a Voltage of 5000 V are taken for Traction Motors Drive
System. Four Tapings of Voltage level of 1000 V are taken for the Auxiliary
Loads with the Assumption that the WRIMs are self-Ventilated and hence do not
requires separate Blowers for Cooling. The WRIMs are rated at 1.6 MW or 1600 kW
each and there are four such Motors to Drive the Axles. Thus for a Six Axle
Locomotive, four Axles will be powered and two Axles will be Dead Axles. This
Configuration is called Bo1-1Bo according to UIC Classification of Locomotives
[8]. The Traction Converter System involves 1-ph to 3-ph conversion by means of
Rectifier-Inverter System. The Auxiliary Circuit consists of both 1-ph to 3-ph
Conversion and 3-ph to 3-ph Conversion by use of a Rectifier-Inverter Circuit
when tapped from Auxiliary Winding of Transformer and low Voltage SPR Drive
respectively. The Auxiliary Windings are connected to three individual 4-Pulse
Rectifier for conversion to DC. On the Rotor side of the Traction Motors, a
3-ph Diode Bridge Rectifier is connected. Each of the 1-ph and 3-ph Rectifiers
are connected to a 3-ph Inverter. These Inverters Drive the Air-Conditioning
Units. For the purpose of Lights and Fans Loads, the fourth Auxiliary Tapping
is connected to 1-ph to 3-ph Conversion System and the Loads are Balanced on
the Ph-Neutral in each of the three-phases after the Voltage has been stepped
Down from 800 V to 110 V. The main Circuit Diagram is shown in Fig.2.
The Circuit
Shown in Fig. 2 was simulated for a Simulation time of 20 seconds. The Embedded
MATLAB Program generated commands for the PWM Generator to deliver Pulses to
the Insulated Gate Bi-polar Transistors at the required Frequency of operation
depending on the Speed of the Locomotive at the Wheel. The Control Strategy
used in this Simulation is constant V/f
to maintain the Torque almost Constant [7], [9]. In order to simulate the 1-ph,
25 kV AC delivered by the Over-Head Equipment, a Voltage Source was connected
to the Main Transformer. The Main Rectifiers converter 1-ph AC to 5000 V DC.
The Harmonics were filtered using LC Filter in the DC Link. The Straight-line
DC was fed to 3-ph Inverter. Each Inverter was connected to a Traction Motor.
The Inverter delivered a 3-ph Voltage of 5800 V with 180 A Current. The
Traction Motors reached their rated Speed after about 0.4 seconds. The commands
for Speed reduction, Braking were given at different intervals to simulate the
running conditions of Locomotives according to the Trapezoidal Speed-Time Curve
for Passenger Services operations which consists of Notching Up, Acceleration,
Free running, Coasting and Braking.
The Circuit
Breakers on the Input side of the Auxiliary Rectifier were initially kept in
Closed Position as there would be no Slip-Power Recovery when the Locomotive
starts. After the Traction Motors reached the required Speed, the Circuit
Breakers were Reset to Open position. The Auxiliary Loads were now entirely fed
from the low Voltage SPR Scheme. Again when the Coasting and Braking mode of
operation was underway, the Circuit Breakers in the Auxiliary Power Circuit
Closed so as to deliver Power to the Loads from the Over-Head Power Lines
through the Auxiliary Winding of the Transformer. Thus, the opening and Closing
of the Circuit Breakers is decided by the Voltage sensed from the Main Traction
Inverter.
The Speed of the
Traction Motors was controlled by means of an Embedded MATLAB program. The
Speed required at the Wheel in kmph was given as
input to the Program. This Speed was in turn converted into Speed in rpm and
matched with the Speed of the Traction Motors measured. If the Speeds were same
no Error was generated. If the Speeds were different, the required new
Frequency of the Inverter was calculated and the output was fed to the PWM
Controller to calculate the required Boost in Inverter Voltage to develop
Constant Torque. The PI Controller was used for the purpose of delivering the
required Gain in Voltage. Thus even though the Speed of the Traction Motors was
varied according to the needs of the Speed of the Locomotive at Wheel, the
Torque was maintained near constant by the V/f
method[8]. The various Graphs of the
3-ph Main Inverter Output Voltage, Auxiliary Inverter Output Voltage, Speed
developed by Traction Motors, Speed developed by Air-Conditioner Compressor
Motors are shown in Figures 3, 4, 5, 6 respectively. The parameters of the
WRIMs used are shown in Table No. 3.The detailed Calculations of Power
delivered to Traction Motors, Slip-Power recovered, Tractive
Effort developed at different Speeds, savings in Fuel are presented in the next
section with necessary Equations and Assumptions.
4. EQUATIONS AND
CALCULATIONS:
The Equations
and Calculations related to the proposed Traction Drive systems are presented
in this section in brief.
4.1
Calculation of Tractive Effort Required:
The various Tractive Efforts required by a Locomotive are [1, 6]:
Tractive
Effort for Acceleration ( Fa):
Tractive
Effort to overcome Gravitational Pull ( Fg ):
Tractive
Effort required to overcome Train Resistance for a Locomotive ( Fr ):
Tractive
Effort required to overcome Curve Resistance
( Fc ):
Total Tractive Effort = Ft
=
4.2
Assumptions for Calculations:
It is assumed that the
Locomotive starts on a plane surface without Gradient and Curvature hence, the Tractive Effort required would be only Tractive
Effort for Acceleration. The Calculations shown in this section are for (i) Shatabdi Expresses and (ii) Rajdhani Expresses. Let us assume that the Locomotive has
to accelerate a trailing Load to 120 Kmph in 304
seconds.
(a)
Calculation of Tractive Effort:
Acceleration,
α in Kmphps will be given as,
Weight of the
Locomotive = Wl = 90 tonnes
(i) For Shatabdi Expresses:
These Trains
normally have 12 coaches. The Coach Composition is given in the Table No.1.
Weight of the
Trailing Load = Wt =
Total Weight = W
= ( Wl
+ Wt ) = 689 tonnes
Effective weight
of Locomotive and Trailing Load =
Tractive
Effort required for Acceleration = Fa =
(ii)
For Rajdhani/Duranto
Expresses:
These Trains
normally have 19 coaches. The Coach Composition is given in the Table No.2.
Weight of the
Trailing Load = Wt =
= 984 Tonnes
Total Weight = W
= ( Wl
+ Wt ) = 1074 tonnes
Effective weight
of Locomotive and Trailing Load =
Tractive
Effort required for Acceleration = Fa =
(b)
Calculation of Power, Torque developed:
Voltage per
phase = 5800 V
Current per
phase = 180 A
Power Factor =
0.9 (Assumed)
Efficiency of
the Machine = 95% (Assumed)
Frequency = 50
Hz, No. Of Poles = 2, Diameter of the Wheel = 1092 mm
Efficiency of
the Gear = 0.9
Gear Ratio for
Passenger Locomotive = Gr
= 3.6
Power input to
the WRIM =
=
= 1627435 Watts
(per Motor)
Power Output per Motor
= 0.95 x 1627435 = 1546 kW
Rated Speed of the
Traction Motors = Ns =
If the Speed of
the Locomotive is 150 Kmph, then the Speed of the
Traction Motors will be Ntm.
=
Torque developed per
Machine =
Total Torque developed
by 4 Traction Motors = Td
= 22509.76 Nm
Tractive
Effort Developed (at Speed of 150 kmph) =
Speed of the Locomotive at Wheel =
=
=
Starting Torque of the Traction Motor =
Total Torque developed
by 4 Traction Motors = Td
= 337444.8 Nm
Tractive
Effort Developed at starting (at Speed of 10 kmph)
=
(c)
Power Required by the Air-conditioned Coaches:
(i) For Shatabdi Coaches:
The Total Connected
Load and the number of Coaches of each type is given in Table No.1. Hence, from
the Table,
The Total Connected
Load for a Train comprising of 12 Coaches is given as,
Assuming a Diversity
Factor of 0.7, the Maximum Demand =
=
(ii)
For Rajdhani Coaches:
The Total Connected Load
and the number of Coaches of each type is given in Table No.2. Hence, from the
Table,
The Total Connected
Load for a Train comprising of 19 Coaches is given as,
Assuming a Diversity
Factor of 0.7, the Maximum Demand =
=
(d)
Calculation of Slip-Power and Total Power Delivered to Air-conditioned Coaches
Air-Gap Power of
one Traction Motor = 1546 kW
Slip (at 150 kmph) =
Theoretical Slip
– Power Recoverable of one Traction Motor when Locomotive Speed is 150 Kmph
=
Slip-Power Recoverable
from four Traction Motors = 2022 kW
Output Voltage of
Auxiliary Winding of Transformer = 1000 V
Output Current of
Auxiliary Converter = 75 A
Output Power at each
Auxiliary Inverter terminals fed from Auxiliary Windings of Transformer when
Traction Motors are at standstill =
Total Output Power from
four Auxiliary Inverters =
Slip-Power Recovered
per Traction Motor (at 150kmph) =
=
Slip-Power Recovered from four Traction Motors =
Diesel consumption per
Hour by the two 500 kW EOG Cars = 100 litres.
If at least one EOG Car
is switched off and Power is taken from the Slip-Power recovered, the Savings
in Diesel for a Shatabdi Express that run for
approximately 14 Hours on one round Trip would be,
=
With Diesel costing
about Rs. 48/- in India, the Amount of money saved per Trip =
For the Whole year, if
the Shatabdi is run for 300 days, the total savings
would be
=
For a Rajdhani Express which on an average runs for 30 Hours in
one Direction, the savings in Diesel would be 1500 litres.
Amount of Money saved per Trip would be = Rs. 72000/- for one way Journey per
Day.
For the Whole year, if Rajdhani runs on all days, the total savings would be
=
5.
ADVANTAGES OF THE PROPOSED CIRCUIT:
The following
are the advantages of the proposed Circuit:
·
Noise and Air Pollution due to EOG is
reduced.
·
Costly Fossil Fuel is saved.
·
Energy is conserved as the low Voltage
Slip-Power Recovery is used instead of drawing Power from the EOG set to aid
the Power delivered by Transformer Auxiliary Windings.
·
This circuit along with Efficient heat
management system inside the coaches by using Sun-Films on Windows will save
lot of Energy and Fuel.
·
The elimination of one EOG Power Car
will be helpful to attach another Passenger Car for the same Tractive Effort required to haul the Train thereby
enhancing the capacity of the Train and also earn more revenue per Trip.
6. CONCLUSIONS:
From
the Simulation Studies carried out with Air-Conditioner Blower Motors rated at
11.5 kW as the Loads on the low Voltage Slip-Power Recovery Drive, it can be
concluded that the Slip-Power generated at Speed range of the Locomotives below
170 Kmph can be fully utilised
to Drive the Air-Conditioning Units and also deliver Power to the Lighting
Loads inside the Coaches of the Trailing Passenger Coaches. In case of Speed of
the Traction Motors being almost the rated Speed, the Power delivered by the
Auxiliary Winding of the Traction Transformer can be utilised
to aid the Slip-Power recovered as the Slip-Power at near rated Speed would be
lesser as compared to at lower Speeds of the Traction Motors. This means that
the need of End-On-Generation with the help of Diesel Generators can be either
partially or totally eliminated in these Trains depending on the Power
delivered by SPR Scheme. The elimination of EOG Power Cars would enable
Railways to add at least three more Passenger Coaches thereby increasing the
Revenue per Train. The elimination of EOG Power Car would also reduce the money
spent on Diesel Oil used for running the Generators. It would also lead to
reduction in noise, air pollution due to emitted smoke and vibration levels in
the Train Sets. Hence, it can be concluded that Head-On-Generation aided by low
Voltage Slip-Power Recovery scheme would lead to Profit making by bringing down
the running Costs involved in buying Diesel Oil and also help in reducing
Pollution in the long run with a very comfortable ride for the Rail Passengers.
Therefore, Traction Drive System with low Voltage Slip Power-Recovery Scheme to
Drive the Locomotive and also deliver Power to Trailing Passenger Coaches is a
viable cost saving option that can be implemented in the Future.
Fig. 1 Schematic
of End-On-Generation for Passenger Coaches
Fig.
2 Proposed Circuit Diagram for Traction and HOG
Fig.3 Traction
Inverter Output Voltages
Fig. 4 Auxiliary
Inverter Output Voltages
Fig. 5 Speed
-Time Curve of Traction Motors
Fig. 6 Speed
developed by Air-Conditioner Compressor Motor
Table
No 1.: Details of Coaches of Shatabdi/Durunto Express Trains (Chair Car Type)
|
S.
No |
Type
of Coach |
Weight
in Tonnes |
Total
Connected Load kW |
No.
Of Coaches |
|
1 |
First AC Chair
Car |
45.30 |
40 |
2 |
|
2 |
Second AC Chair
Car |
47.3 |
40 |
8 |
|
3 |
EOG –
Diesel Generator Cars |
65 |
49 |
2 |
Table
No 2.: Details of Coaches of Rajdhani/Duranto Express Trains (Sleeper Type)
|
S.
No |
Type
of Coach |
Weight
in Tonnes |
Total
Connected Load in kW |
No.
Of Coaches |
|
1 |
First AC 2-Tier
Sleeper |
46.60 |
15.75 |
1 |
|
2 |
AC 2-Tier
Sleeper |
48.8 |
34.75 |
6 |
|
3 |
AC 3-Tier
Sleeper |
51.36 |
40 |
8 |
|
4 |
Pantry Car |
51.90 |
76.75 |
2 |
|
5 |
EOG –
Diesel Generator Cars |
65 |
49 |
2 |
Table 3: Traction
Motors Parameters:
|
S.
No |
Parameter |
Traction
Motors |
|
1. |
Rated Voltage |
5000 V |
|
2. |
Rated Power |
1600 kW |
|
3. |
Operating Frequency |
50 Hz |
|
4. |
Efficiency |
95 % |
|
5. |
Power factor |
0.9 lag |
|
6. |
No. Of poles |
2 poles |
7.
REFERENCES:
[1]
Anula Khare, Saroj Rangnekar
"Hotel Load in Indian Railways: Energy Conservation in EOG Scheme",
International Journal of Emerging Trends - 2011.
[2] Ministry of Railways, Government of India,
“General Services- Train Lighting”, IRIEEN, Nashik,
India
[3]
H. Partab
“Modern Electric Traction” Publisher: Dhanpat Rai and Sons, India –
2012.
[4] Paul Blaiklock, William Horvath “Saving
Energy” TMEIC GE, USA – Motor Technology
September-2009
[5]
ABB Motors and Generators – “Brochure
on Slip Ring Motors for heavy-duty and critical Applications”-
2011.
[6]
J. Upadhyaya
and S.N. Mahendra “Electric Traction”, Allied Publishers India – 2000.
[7]
S. S. Chirmurkar,
M. V. Palandurkar and S. G. Tarnekar
“Torque Control of Induction motor using V/f
Method” International Journal of
Advances in Engineering Sciences, Vol.1, Issue 1, Jan 2011.
[8] Toby J Nicholson “DC and AC
Traction Motors”. IET Professional Development
Course in Traction Systems 3-7 Nov 2008, Manchester Pages34-44.
[9]
Rupesh Kumar
“Course on Three Phase Technology in TRS Applications” IRIEEN, Nasik, India – Aug.2010.
Received on 25.05.2015 Accepted on 25.07.2015
©A&V Publications all right reserved
Research
J. Engineering and Tech. 6(4): Oct. - Dec., 2015 page 399-407
DOI: 10.5958/2321-581X.2015.00062.8